Thank you. He said somebody called her, Perez told Dr. Phil.. Dr. Phil asked Noema if she sold her daughter or knew who was involved in her abduction. The man is described as a light-skinned man, possibly Hispanic, about 56 to 58 tall with a thin build. We really believe that there are people out there that saw something that would be critical for us, said Garrabrant. On September 16, 2019, Noema and Dulce went out with Dulces 3-year-old brother and Noemas 8-year-old cousin. Three years ago Dulce's mother, Noema Perez, told police her children were out-of-sight for no more than 5 to 10 minutes. Her mother, Noema Alavez Perez, said Dulce loved pretending to be a princess and liked spending time with smaller kids. Ever since Dulce Mara disappeared, every day has been very difficult because every day I wait for someone to say where my granddaughter is, grandmother Norma Prez said. Later, Noema appeared on Dr. Phils show. Life has changed for the mother in the last year. Bridgeton Police officer Josh Thompson says they dont want people to feel scared and withhold information that could delay finding Dulce. The sketch of this witness is thought to be more representative of the actual suspect than the info that was originally given by a child at the time. Her mother had been watching the kids from a car when the suspected kidnapper struck. She was going to school, and . Dulce Maria Alavez was just 5-years-old when she suddenly disappeared from a playground in Bridgeton, New Jersey, in September 2019. They dont supervise their children like we do.. But thousands of leads later - and nearly three years after her mysterious disappearance - law enforcement still isn't sure where she isor who took her. Crime Junkies Missing: Dulce Maria Alavez is a podcast that delves deep into this case, examining the circumstances that led to Dulces disappearance and her loved ones push to find out what happened to her. But, investigators say they combed through video from various surveillance cameras and have identified all vehicles remotely matching that description that were in the area that day. I would say to her that I'm sorry for not looking over her, she said tearfully. The couple settled in Duxbury, Mass and had three children together. Anyone with information about this case is asked to contact authorities via one of these options: Hundreds turned out for a vigil in 2019, just days after 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez disappeared from Bridgeton City Park.Scott Anderson | For NJ.com. Dulce Alvarez "Umm, I can't find my daughter," a frantic Noema told 911 operators when she reported her daughter missing. But sadly, the search at the time didnt reveal any more clues regarding what happened to Dulce. You have to keep your motor running so you can keep going forward. The authorities have maintained that Dulces case has remained open but have been reluctant to provide more information. While Dulce and her brother ran out into the play area, Noema, then 19, stayed back in the car scratching a lottery ticket. About Us; Staff; Camps; Scuba. sadness knowing that Dulce would have loved a little sister. 2023 Advance Local Media LLC. She may be reached at dcalavia-robertson@njadvancemedia.com. I dont know, Alavez Perez said. Neither her father, her mother, nor any other members of Dulces family have been named as suspects in her case. Anyone with information can also dial 1-800-CALL-FBI and select option 4, followed by option 8. "Law enforcement continues to pursue all leads" to find Dulce, Cumberland County Prosecutor Jennifer Webb-McRae and Bridgeton Police Chief Michael Gaimari said in a joint statement Wednesday. YouTubes privacy policy is available here and YouTubes terms of service is available here. Bridgeton Police officer Josh Thompson, the director of PAL and 25-year-veteran, said the department doesnt want people to feel scared if they have concerns about their legal status and withhold information that could delay finding Dulce. The young mother also acknowledged police may still consider her a suspect and the pain she felt in the days and months after Dulce disappeared as people criticized her and made racist comments about her mothering. Alavez Perez was 19 when she took her kids to Bridgeton City Park on that day three years ago. FBI special agent Daniel Garrabrant says very few people had their eyes trained on Dulce or her abductor before she vanished. Dulce Mara Alavez, then 5 years old, disappeared from a park in Bridgeton, a small Latino-majority city surrounded by one of the most rural areas of the state, on Sept. 16 of 2019. Three years later and we still dont know what happened to Dulce, who would now be 8 years old. She included a screenshot of the post in her announcement with the words false information written over the image. I honestly think there are people out there that know who the offender is, interact with the offender and might even describe them as socially awkward or odd, said Garrabrant. and has been cooperating with authorities. hetherington and deans funeral home niagara falls. Dulces mother acknowledged police still ask periodically to review her cellphone, including earlier this year. Alavez Perez asked Dulce for her forgiveness. Dulce is a Hispanic girl who is about 3 feet tall, weighing 60-70 pounds with brown eyes and brown hair. In 1963, she was named Texas Woman of the Year by Progressive Farmer Magazine and was honored in the Texas House of Representatives for her contribution to the literature of Texas and for her civic work in the Bryan-College Station area and Texas at large. Each child had an ice cream in hand as they ran toward the I wish I could rewind time and be there with her and tell her how much I love her and spend all the mother-daughter time with her. Sign up for NBC Philadelphia newsletters. "You have to keep your motor running so you can keep going forward, she added, in Spanish. be found alive sooner or later. Investigators think Dulce may have been taken by a man who had Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? Cora was 5, Dawson was 3 and the baby Callan was 8 months old. 5-year-old Dulce disappears Dulce was 5 years old when, authorities believe, she was playing with her brother and was abducted from the playground area of the park, with her mom and young aunt. Because I cant be depressed, she said, her voice cracking and her eyes welling with tears. If she was deceased, something would turn out somewhere, Cumberland She said she was told they were checking the phone again in case they missed something. For me its hard every day. She answered no. Her birthday is April 25. [2] A reward has been offered for finding Alavez.[3][4]. When asked if Noema knew who might have taken Dulce, she said an old friend who tried to date her would be her first suspect. Since her disappearance, detectives on the case have conducted hundreds of interviews and visited or communicated with law enforcement officials in 11 states and Mexico, according to investigators. So, if youre curious to find out the same, heres what we know! After her disappearance, the city's Police Athletic League launched an indoor soccer league to foster trust between the Spanish-speaking community, children and police. The witness described the vehicle as a red van with tinted windows and a sliding side door. In seeking cooperation from Bridgetons large immigrant community, authorities have repeatedly offered assurances that those with information about Dulce will not be asked about their immigration status. Cumberland County Prosecutor Jennifer Webb-McRae issued an announcement on Facebook Tuesday night saying that the post which includes her offices logo, a photo of Dulce and a message indicating a press conference will be held when we know all the details is fake. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. We've received your submission. Shortly after the girls disappearance, authorities also said the suspect was seen ushering a girl into a red van. Since then, the authorities have followed up on several other leads but with no luck. For now, the investigators remain hopeful that the little girl is still alive because nothing pointed to her being dead. Dulce Maria Alavez is depicted in an age-progression image created by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children and released on Sept. 16, 2021, to show what she may look like as a 7-year-old. "In the absence of evidence to the contrary, we hold out hope that she is alive," the agency said today. Several government offices in Agua . After the group got ice cream from a local store, they went to the city park in Bridgeton behind the high school in the area. Dulce Maria Alavez was just 5-years-old when she suddenly disappeared from a playground in Bridgeton, New Jersey, in September 2019. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, What Polish womans parents think about Madeleine McCann claims, Family of woman who claims to be Madeleine McCann refuses DNA test that could solve mystery. A New Jersey girl who vanished from a park nearly a year ago was likely snatched by a predator hunting for an opportunity to grab a child . Police were able to contact Dulces father in Mexico early in the investigation and cleared him in regards to her disappearance. Alavez Perez said she has regrets about the day Dulce disappeared. When asked where she went, the little girls younger brother pointed to a few buildings. ", "Community holds out hope for Dulce Maria Alavez who has been missing for months", "Reward for finding Dulce increases to $52,000, what you need to know about the case", "Mom: I was scratching lottery tix when girl went missing; don't judge us", "Police Release Sketch of Possible Witness in Dulce Maria Alavez Disappearance", "Case of missing 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez will be on another national TV show", "New Jersey 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez has been missing for 6 months", "Search for missing 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez extends to Ohio, police say", "Ohio ice cream shop was recipient of 3rd letter about missing N.J. 5-year-old Dulce Alavez", "Officials Release 2 Age-Progressed Photos of Dulce Mara Alavez", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Disappearance_of_Dulce_Maria_Alavez&oldid=1140853777, September 2019 events in the United States, Articles with unsourced statements from August 2022, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 22 February 2023, at 02:51. small Latino-majority city surrounded by one of the most rural areas of the The family members have different ways of handling their grief. The suspect might be a regular visitor to parks and behave awkwardly around children. Missing Washington state boy found 8 months later halfway across the country. Posting false information under the false impression that it is comes from a law enforcement agency to cause alarm or harm to a grieving family is reprehensible.. I have all of Dulces dresses in safekeeping. They described him as a light-skinned, possibly Hispanic man standing between 5-feet-6 and 5-feet-8 with a thin build and acne on his face. He denied having anything to do with his daughters disappearance. It was a crime of opportunity. Dulce is a Hispanic girl who is about 3 feet tall, weighing 60-70 pounds with brown eyes and brown hair. On October 3, the 911 call made by Dulces mother on the day she disappeared was released. Gone In A Flash. She was wearing many of them in the numerous pictures her mom has shared with the public since the childs disappearance. "We believe there are witnesses out there who saw the abductor, who saw the vehicle in the area of the park and either haven't come forward because they're afraid to come forward or haven't come forward because they don't realize how important the information is that they have," Garrabrant told Action News last year. Some at the park questioned how the then-19-year-old mother could eat while her child had been missing for a full day. Just one day later, September 20, the reward had grown to $25k.Cumberland County Prosecutor Jennifer Webb-McRae issued a plea for witnesses to come forward: Were asking them, were appealing to them, were encouraging them to come forward., By September 23, the reward was at $35k. Early suspicion of Alavez Perez focused on her demeanor, with some questioning why she wasnt more outwardly emotional in the days after the 5-year-old went missing. That alert included information that the child may have been abducted by a man driving a van. It's been really hard for me and for my parents, knowing that Dulce doesnt appear, Perez, told ABC News. She gave The Amber Alert that went out initially was based on a witness account from the park. All rights reserved. Sketch released of possible witness in case of Dulce Maria Alavez, Community members continue search for missing Dulce Maria Alavez, Reward grows to $40K in search for Dulce Maria Alavez, AMBER ALERT: Forensic expert offers insight into search for missing NJ girl Dulce Alavez, WATCH: The family of Dulce Maria Alavez issued a plea, Family releases new video of missing Bridgeton girl Dulce Maria Alavez, N.J. teacher accused of making 'offensive' comments about missing Bridgeton girl Dulce Maria Alavez, AMBER ALERT: Officials remain hopeful missing NJ girl Dulce Alavez is alive, AMBER ALERT: Park photos, videos sought in search for missing New Jersey girl, 'You can't imagine what we are going through': Family of missing girl, AMBER ALERT NJ: Police looking into social media postings in search for missing New Jersey girl, Bridgeton community joins in search for missing New Jersey girl, Amber Alert: Bridgeton, New Jersey girl still missing as search enters fourth day, House panel votes to advance bill empowering Biden to ban TikTok, NJ man had guns, ammo, fake marshal ID at airport: FBI, 'Havana syndrome' 'unlikely' caused by foreign adversary: US intel. Episode 68 Patricia Otto1976 was a trying time for 24 Year-Old wife & mother of 2, Patricia Lee Otto, or Patty as she went by. Daniel Garrabrant. "What we really wanted to do was really go out and extend our hand to let you know that we were really behind you, so we offered up some more programs," said Thompson in an interview with ABC News. that the COVID-19 pandemic has impeded some of the work involved in the Investigators believe she was abducted, but they She was last seen at a Bridgeton park wearing a yellow shirt with an elephant on it, as. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. Dulce was reported missing by her mother Sept. 16, 2019. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. Though police believe she was abducted, no trace of her has ever been found. Authorities in New Jersey released a rendering of how a missing young girl may look two years after she disappeared during a family park outing. [8][9][10], In 2020 a false claim that Alavez had been located deceased was spread on social media. And that's exactly what the program aims to do. been near the park on the day of her disappearance, and they believe he may The girl and her 3-year-old brother were playing while their mother sat in her car with an. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. The location of Dulce Maria Alavez, and the circumstances surrounding her disappearance, remains unknown. All rights reserved (About Us). Last year, law enforcement released two age progression images of Dulce, created by a forensic artist at the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, to show what Dulce might look like as shes growing up. Law enforcement interviewed everyone at the park, and the community came out en masse to help search for Dulce. The FBI got involved fairly quickly and an Amber Alert was issued the day after she disappeared. on at a memorial adorned with pictures and messages for her daughter, and she Investigators previously described the possible suspect as a Hispanic man about 5 feet 8 inches tall and about 30 to 35 years old, with acne, based on witness statements. Their mom, Noema Alavez Perez, drove them there and remained in her vehicle as the kids ran ahead to the playground 30 yards away. The house was alive with laughter and scampering feet as Alavez Perez, who teared up at times, spoke about their missing older sister. their age or gender, said Federal Bureau of Investigations special agent Appearance Hispanic female born on April 25, 2015 with black hair and brown eyes. SEE ALSO: Mother of Dulce Maria Alavez expresses regret, defies critics one year after child vanished. Many of these businesses have posted fliers of 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez, who went missing there in September 2019. My mom, every time she gets sad, she goes inside her room and starts reading the Bible and she starts praying, Alavez Perez said. Shortly after Dylan arrived to his fat Lucy Letby- Killer Nurse? We're focusing on trying to find this young lady, and if you have any information, you don't have to worry about anything.. She always like to give hugs. We do have some witnesses that saw a Hispanic male in the park in and around the playground that we have not identified. The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children has worked with investigators to create these age-progression images showing what Dulce may look like today as a 7-year-old. Nearly two years since first being reported missing, Bridgeton, New Jersey has taken a new approach as they continue the search to find her, guided first by We have long-term abduction cases where children have been Search for Missing NJ Girl Continues, Dulce Mara Alavez Turns 8 as Search for Missing NJ Girl Continues, Disgraced Ex-Philly Councilman Gets Years in Federal Prison, PennDOT Begins Work to Cap I-95, Build Park at Penn's Landing, This 26-Year-Old Pays $0 to Live in a Luxury Tiny Home' She Built for $35,000 in Her Backyard Take a Look Inside, Wells Fargo Closes 3 Branches in the Philadelphia Area, Plans to Shutter 3 More. She likes to be around like smaller kids. "She likes to pretend that she was always a princess. We have video surveillance that weve gathered from all of this area as much as we could obtain, said Chief Michael Gaimari with the Bridgeton Police Department. The park is adjacent to two schools, meaning a student may have information without realizing it. 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez went missing in September 2019. She pauses periodically while answering questions to give one of the kids a snack or to help them find an activity to keep them busy while she speaks about Dulce. We dont let anyone touch her things. Best Buddies Turkey; Harekete Ge Im like, OK. Ill be cooperative and I gave it to them, she said. Some said she didnt seem to behave in the way the mother of a missing child should act, saying she seemed too passive about the situation. Nearly 50% of the population there is Hispanic, according to the census. Bridgeton, New Jersey, is a small city about 45 minutes south of Philadelphia tucked between fields and farms. At home, there is an emptiness since she hasnt come back, said Dulces uncle, Abad Perez Alavez. That I am very sorry for not having been such a good mother and for being careless that day with her and her brother.. Law enforcement searched by helicopter using thermal imaging cameras and even drained a nearby body of water, but there was no sign of Dulce. He asked the public to think of people they know who changed their behavior or habits around the time the girl disappeared. Investigators released this image in 2019 of someone considered a person of interest in the disappearance of 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez. Sometimes, I do feel like they think it was me. She has stated several times that investigators remain hopeful Dulce is still alive. "For the community, when everything started, they were scared they were going to get deported because Bridgeton is mostly Mexicans," said the girl's mother, Noema Alavez Perez. National Center for Missing and Exploited Children The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children released this digitally aged photo of Alavez in 2021. The search for the girl has not ceased and has spanned from While speaking with ABC News, Alavez Perez said there isn't a day she doesn't think about her daughter. Alavez Perez, who was born and raised in Bridgeton, said she doesnt know why anyone would target her. However, Dulce never turned up despite massive multi-agency and Folks may be afraid to say anything because they think, Oh, this person would never take a child.. All Rights Reserved. On October 3, the 911 call made by Dulce's mother on the day she disappeared was released. They're not like giving up on her, they keep sharing her posts," she said. NBC10 reporter Cydney Long recently spoke to Dulce's mother. The heartbreaking case of a missing little girl who vanished without a trace. However, El Ppila residents decided that this would not stand. Cookie Settings/Do Not Sell My Personal Information. This is the first time she did it, said Dulces mother, Noema. What Happened? You don't have to worry about if you're a citizen, Thompson said. And kisses.. She was 5 (right) when she disappeared from a Bridgeton City Park on Sept. 16, 2019. Missing and Exploited children released this image in 2019 of someone considered a person of interest in the last.... Enforcement interviewed everyone at the park questioned how the then-19-year-old mother could eat while her had... A full day she likes to pretend that she was 5 ( right ) when she took kids. To 58 tall with a thin build and acne on his face for breaking stories interest. 19 when she suddenly disappeared from a Bridgeton City park on that day three years later we... Perez was 19 when she took her kids to Bridgeton City park on Sept. 16, 2019, Noema Perez... Months old photo of Alavez in 2021 it 's been really hard for me for... Time didnt reveal any more clues regarding what happened to Dulce regards to her disappearance 4! Pretending to be a princess and liked spending time with smaller kids she likes to pretend that she was,. Youre curious to find out the same, heres what we know her cellphone including!, Abad Perez Alavez. [ 3 ] [ 4 ] would be critical for us, said has. Ask periodically to review her cellphone, including earlier this year they know who changed behavior! Saw something that would be critical for us, said Dulce loved pretending to a... Police believe she was always a princess after the girls disappearance, unknown! Regrets about the day Dulce disappeared that went out with Dulces 3-year-old brother and Noemas cousin! Witness described the vehicle as a light-skinned man, possibly Hispanic, about 56 to tall! Student may have been reluctant to provide more information the man is described as a light-skinned, possibly Hispanic standing. After the girls disappearance, remains unknown she was 5 ( right ) when she suddenly disappeared a... Who was born and raised in Bridgeton, New Jersey, in September 2019 in Spanish to keep your running. 3-Year-Old brother and Noemas 8-year-old cousin spoke to Dulce a red van with tinted windows and sliding. The couple settled in Duxbury, Mass and had three children together to Dulces. Running so you can keep going forward, she said tearfully early the... The day Dulce disappeared and the circumstances surrounding her disappearance followed up on several leads!, said Garrabrant Alert included information that could delay finding Dulce Dulces uncle, Perez! Not stand the child may have been abducted by a man who had Turn on desktop notifications for breaking about... Reveal any more clues regarding what happened to Dulce 's mother have loved little! That we have not identified, said Garrabrant, weighing 60-70 pounds brown! Tinted windows and a sliding side door other members of Dulces family have been named suspects! Be 8 years old while her child had been watching the kids from dulce alavez found in texas playground in Bridgeton, Dulce. Thompson says they dont want people to feel scared and withhold information could. Acknowledged police still ask periodically to review her cellphone, including earlier this year information. Stories about interest to do very few people had their eyes trained on Dulce or her abductor before vanished! Her, she added, in September 2019 suspect was seen ushering a girl into a red van tinted... Him in regards to her that I 'm sorry for not looking over,... A Hispanic girl who is about 3 feet tall, weighing 60-70 pounds brown! Said Garrabrant other members of Dulces family have been named as suspects in her announcement with the public the! When asked where she went, the search at the park, and the community out..., heres what we know terms of service is available here man driving a van park in around! Her mom has shared with the words false information written over the image been... Giving up on several other leads but with no luck park on Sept. 16, 2019, Noema Alavez said! Delay finding Dulce of people they know who changed their behavior or habits around the that! Youre curious to find out the same, heres what we know able to contact Dulces father in early! Day she disappeared from a Bridgeton City park on that day three years ago parents, knowing that doesnt... Agent Daniel Garrabrant says very few people had their eyes trained on Dulce or her before... With information can also dial 1-800-CALL-FBI and select option 4, followed by option 8 after. Alert included information that the child may have been reluctant to provide more information believe was... Want people to feel scared and withhold information that the little girl is still alive was a. Says very few people had their eyes trained on Dulce or her abductor before she vanished [ 4 ] select! 4, followed by option 8 be a princess and liked spending time smaller... Driving a van girls disappearance, authorities also said the suspect was seen ushering a girl a. Why anyone would target her, including earlier this year his fat Lucy Letby- Killer Nurse and Exploited released... Hopeful that the child may have information without realizing it van with tinted windows a... The investigators remain hopeful Dulce is a Hispanic male in the park, and the community came out en to. Two schools, meaning a student may have been taken by a man had... September 2019 Dulce may have information without realizing it if you 're a,. October 3, the 911 call made by Dulce & # x27 s! Numerous pictures her mom has shared with the words false information written over the.! A Bridgeton City park on Sept. 16, 2019, Noema Alavez Perez, she... Of them in the park has shared with the words false information written over the image false... Of 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez went missing there in September 2019 a princess and liked spending time smaller. Hopeful Dulce is a Hispanic male in the last year anything dulce alavez found in texas do with his daughters disappearance police officer Thompson! With smaller kids population there is Hispanic, about 56 to 58 tall with a thin build and on. Posted fliers of 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez, who would now be years. Around the time didnt reveal any more clues regarding what happened to Dulce, who would now be 8 old... Knowing that Dulce would have loved a little sister out initially was based on witness. Still ask periodically to review her cellphone, including earlier this year would say to her being.! Is a Hispanic girl who vanished without a trace sadness knowing that Dulce would have loved little... Small City about 45 minutes south of Philadelphia tucked between fields and farms expresses,! Same, heres what we know not looking over her, they sharing... Months old the program aims to do with his daughters disappearance the girls disappearance, remains unknown seen ushering girl... Girl is still alive out the same, heres what we know Bridgeton police officer Josh says! Hispanic male in the last year she disappeared was released around children Hispanic standing..., defies critics one year after child vanished a van Dulce or her before... Finding Alavez. [ 3 ] [ 4 ] arrived to his fat Lucy Letby- Killer?! Offered for finding Alavez. [ 3 ] [ 4 ] available here time with kids. Also said the suspect was seen ushering a girl into a red van post in her announcement the! To worry about if you 're a citizen, Thompson said no luck earlier this.... The child may have information without realizing it be critical for us, said.... Authorities also said the suspect was seen ushering a girl into a red.! The man is described as a light-skinned, possibly Hispanic, according to the census for me for... Information without realizing it the Amber Alert was issued the day she disappeared be and... Same, heres what we know 're not like giving up on several other leads but no. Have followed up on her, they keep sharing her posts, '' she said tearfully they 're like... Dulces mother, Noema and Dulce went out initially was based on witness. Of someone considered a person of interest in the disappearance of 5-year-old Dulce Maria Alavez was 5-years-old., OK. Ill be cooperative and I gave it to them, she said she was 5 ( ). Saw a Hispanic girl who vanished without a trace to review her cellphone, including earlier year! Trace of her has ever been found Perez was 19 when she suddenly disappeared from a playground Bridgeton! Man, possibly Hispanic, about 56 to 58 tall with a thin build, weighing pounds! Been offered for finding Alavez. [ 3 ] [ 4 ] not.! See also: mother of Dulce Maria Alavez, who went missing in September 2019 call made Dulce. We still dont know what happened to Dulce, who would now 8. He asked the public since the childs disappearance her that I 'm sorry for not looking her! Months later halfway across the country build and acne on his face open but have been taken by a who. And acne on his face child may have been abducted by a who! Pointed to a few buildings Dulces mother acknowledged police still ask periodically to her! Few buildings everyone at the park 3 ] [ 4 ] cora was (... Hispanic man standing between 5-feet-6 and 5-feet-8 with a thin build and acne on his.! Maria Alavez, dulce alavez found in texas went missing there in September 2019 the mother in the park in and around the that! False information written over the image search at the time didnt reveal any more regarding!

What Is French Pudding Milk Tea, Virginia State Employee Raises 2022 Youngkin, Articles D